Let's Chat
Blog | Livestream recap

What to Say When a Tired Landlord Says No to Your First Question

A no isn't the end of the story. Here are the two follow-up questions I ask tired landlords, and why I go for three nos before I move on.

By Josh Schoenly |

Watch: ๐Ÿ”ด What to Say When a Tired Landlord Says No: The First Question (LIVE)

This was week three of our month-long series on tired landlords and absentee owners. Today's question: what do we do, and what do we say, when a tired landlord says no to our first question?

The short answer is that "no isn't the end of the story." When I'm talking with someone who owns multiple properties, I don't give up after one no. I go for three. Here's the exact tactic, the strategy behind it, and how it applies way beyond tired landlords.

The first question

If you missed week one, here's the first question we ask by phone, text and email. It's very simple. Are you open to an offer on the property at 123 Maple Street? On the phone it sounds like this:

"I know this is probably a long shot, but is there any chance you'd consider an offer on your property at 123 Maple Street?"

Our reason to reach out is that we have a buyer or an offer for their property. Otherwise, we don't reach out. And if the answer is anything other than a positive reply, we don't just give up and move on to the next one. We go for three nos.

No number one: ask about the rest of the portfolio

Say they tell you they're happy with it, they've got a great long-term tenant, and so on. Okay, great. Then I ask:

"Do you have any other properties in your portfolio that you might consider an offer on right now?"

It's a simple ask, and very little negative can come from it. That one question, asked by an agent using LeadDeck to a tired landlord at the beginning of this year, has led to multiple closed transactions for me, with another one actively on the market. The owner said no, not really, but they did have other properties they were thinking about selling. You just never know.

No number two: ask if they're buying

If they say no again, maybe "we're pretty happy with our portfolio," I ask:

"Are you looking to or interested in adding to your portfolio now or anytime in the near future?"

These are great people to talk to. It's hard to get three nos from tired landlords, out-of-state absentee owners or absentee owners in your local market. I've done it, but it's rare when you're talking with people who own multiple properties. They have a propensity to do deals.

And even after three nos, I'll ask for permission to keep in touch.

When you don't know if they own more

These follow-up questions fit tired landlords because we already know they own more than one property. That context helps us ask better questions.

But what if we don't know? I'm not going to assume they don't own other properties. If any property owner tells me they're not open to an offer, I still ask the follow-up. That question has led me to vacant land listings and multifamily properties.

One conversation, many transactions

Last fall I reached out to an owner about a parcel of vacant land because I had a pocket buyer looking for land just like it. I was just following the blueprint. A pocket buyer gives me a reason to have conversations with people more likely to transact.

This one was actually a yes. We listed and sold the land. And as I built the relationship, he told me he had a two-unit income property he was looking to sell. He'd even talked with another agent he was going to list it with. But I was having a different conversation. I was bringing him what he was really looking for: not a listing agent, but a buyer and an actual offer. That's why we start with buyers in the 1 Deal A Week blueprint.

While he was getting the two-unit ready, I simply asked, "Hey, if I brought you an acceptable offer in the meantime, would you be totally opposed to looking at that?" I found him a buyer using our exact blueprint and sold it off market. That buyer is now a pocket buyer and pocket seller for me. Then I helped the owner buy land farther up in Pennsylvania, he plans to have me list the subdivided parcels, and he's referred me another client.

All of that came from one conversation with an absentee owner in a little over 12 months.

One note for the yes path: if they say yes to an offer, you'll still want to ask about their other properties. That question just happens later in the conversation or later in the relationship. Don't drop the ball there.

Read the room

When you get a no, especially one that's friendly and cooperative, lean in, get curious and ask more questions. Some people will tell you no more aggressively. Use those context clues to decide whether and how you pivot.

But more often than not, with people who own multiple properties, there's something in their portfolio they'd consider an offer on, or they're looking to buy. Either way, there's potential for a positive outcome.

The bigger principle

If we want to close more transactions the rest of this year, and especially in 2027, we simply need more reasons to have more conversations with more people more likely to transact. Tired landlords, absentee owners and out-of-state absentee owners are more likely to transact. When we keep those conversations going past the first no, we'll naturally be writing more contracts.

If you want to work through this with other agents doing the same thing, join our free Skool community, 1 Deal A Week In Real Estate.

Key takeaways

  • A no to your first question isn't the end of the story. Go for three nos.
  • After no number one, ask if they have any other properties they'd consider an offer on right now.
  • After no number two, ask if they're looking to add to their portfolio now or in the near future.
  • Even after three nos, ask permission to keep in touch.
  • Ask the portfolio question even when you don't know they own more. You never know.
  • Read the room. Lean in on a friendly no, and use context clues on a firm one.

Chapters

  • 00:00 When a tired landlord says no
  • 01:00 The first question
  • 03:30 No number one: other properties in the portfolio
  • 05:30 No number two: adding to the portfolio
  • 07:00 When you don't know if they own more
  • 08:00 One conversation, many transactions
  • 13:00 Read the room
  • 14:30 What's coming up this week
tired landlordsabsentee ownersout of state absentee ownersprospecting scriptsobjection handlingthree nosreverse offer strategy1 Deal A Week blueprint

Want more like this?

Join 1,500+ agents in the free 1 Deal A Week In Real Estate community.

Buying, selling or investing in Central PA? Visit Hampden Township Living, my local real estate site.
Let's chat with Josh โ†’