Let's Chat
Blog | Livestream recap

Cold Calling Out-of-State Owners LIVE: How I Get Lines in the Water

Watch me build a small pond of out-of-state absentee owners around a real pocket buyer, then call, voicemail, text, email and mail each card.

By Josh Schoenly |

Watch: Cold Calling Real Estate: How to Get Listings From Out-of-State Owners (Live)

This was the day we'd been building to all week. After covering why out-of-state absentee owners, how to find them, what to say to get them to raise their hand, and what to say when they reply, I went live and prospected them myself.

Results vary, and nothing here is a guarantee. What I want you to see is the process: build a small pond around a real reason to reach out, then call, leave a voicemail, text, email and, when it makes sense, send mail. Lines in the water on every card.

Start with a real reason: a pocket buyer

The inspiration for today's pond was a conversation I'd had about half an hour before going live. A buyer, referred to me by another eXp agent, gave me his exact buy box. Later that day I set him up on MLS search alerts. But I don't rely on that.

That's the 1 Deal A Week blueprint in action. Buyers, sellers and reverse offers, and it's a continuum. With the reverse offer strategy, "we're going to make offers to get clients. We're not going to wait around for clients to make offers." So "we don't wait around and play the MLS slot machine." I use my buyer as the reason to have more conversations, in this case with out-of-state absentee owners in the towns he wants.

Stack lists so the pond is worth fishing

Being an out-of-state owner alone doesn't make someone motivated. It's the first signal. Then I stack other possible motivators on top: an involuntary lien, a tax default, vacant, inherited, pre-foreclosure, tired landlord (owns more than one property), senior.

Plenty of those stacks came back empty this morning. That's fine. A few stacks hit, and a small list is plenty when you work the whole process on each card. I also like starting with the smallest deck first. Knocking one out feels like progress, and it gets me moving faster.

Research the card before you dial

Each card shows the owners, the property details, phones and emails. Before calling I can Google the owner, Google the address, pull up the property on a listing site, or run an AI search to check for any listing history. No listing history can be a clue that they're the original owners.

I can also look at preliminary offer options and buyers right on the card. So even if I didn't have a pocket buyer, I'd still have a reason to reach out.

Dead numbers and the DNC

The first card had a disconnected number. I marked it wrong number and hid it so it doesn't waste time next pass. A number on the DNC isn't an automatic stop. I Google it to see if it's publicly marketed, like a Google Business Profile or a for rent by owner listing. If it isn't, I hide it and move on.

When the phones strike out, the emails don't. I send to every email on the account, then tap to enrich the card for more contact details. Look at how emails are built, too. A first name plus a common nickname of the last name at Gmail, or first initial, middle initial, last name at Gmail, usually means you've found the real person. And since I'm sending a personal, peer-to-peer email with their name and property, there's a real expectation of a reply.

The voicemail and text I leave

When I get a working mobile that isn't on the DNC, I call. If it goes to voicemail, I introduce myself and my brokerage, name the property, and say something like this:

"I know this is probably a long shot, but I'm wondering if there's any chance you'd be open to an offer"

Then I explain that I have a private client looking to buy, ideally before the end of the year but possibly early 2027, and there just isn't much on the market that fits. I close with "If you could do me a huge favor and let me know either way" and tell them "when I hang up I'm going to shoot you a text from my personal cell phone as well."

Then I tap to text with the prepopulated message: "Just left you a voicemail." Then I send the emails. Three lines in the water with one person. If they don't reply to the first attempt, the nudge comes later: a question mark by text or three question marks by email. They may not be a yes, but "no isn't the end of the road." Usually it's a not right now, and that opens the door to a future contract.

Wrong numbers and hard-to-reach owners

One call reached someone who wasn't the owner. I apologized and asked if they had any properties in central PA they'd like to sell. No. Worth a shot.

That owner was hard to track down. Disconnected, DNC, and a people search number that didn't work either. Here's why I keep digging: the harder someone is to reach, the harder they are for everyone to reach. When you're the one who gets through, there's less competition. Like drilling for oil, "the deeper you dig, the better the oil."

For owners like that, I set up direct mail. It's three pieces: a letter, then a note card, then a postcard. The message is the same as the voicemail. Would you be open to an offer? I have a private client looking to make one.

Out-of-state owners tend to have more outdated data, so I send to every email on the card. It costs nothing, and each one is a line in the water, even if only a couple of them look most likely to be accurate.

Time zones matter

Near the end, one owner lived in a state that doesn't do daylight saving time. Rather than risk calling at 7:30 in the morning their time, I saved him for later. Small thing, but it's part of being the friendly, respectful voice they actually want to call back.

What's next

Next week we lean in on local absentee owners and layer on more criteria. If you've missed any of this series, there are playlists on the channel for the raw and edited versions.

If you want the resources from this series and want to work through it with other agents, join our free Skool community, 1 Deal A Week In Real Estate. Look in the Classroom tab under new member bonuses.

Key takeaways

  • Start with a real reason to reach out. A real pocket buyer's buy box is perfect bait.
  • Out-of-state ownership is the first signal. Stack other motivators, and don't worry if the list is small.
  • Research the card first, hide dead numbers, and check DNC numbers for public marketing before you skip them.
  • On a working mobile: voicemail, then a text saying you just left a voicemail, then email. Three lines in the water with one person.
  • Hard-to-reach owners often have less competition. Dig deeper, send to every email, and use direct mail.
  • Mind their time zone, and nudge later with a question mark by text or three by email.

Chapters

  • 00:00 Live Prospecting Strategy Session
  • 01:50 The LeadDeck Easy Button
  • 03:18 The 1 Deal A Week Blueprint
  • 04:41 Stacking Lists for Better Leads
  • 10:04 Working Leads in Smart Mode
  • 22:45 Live Calling and Voicemail Scripts
  • 39:40 Reflecting on the Prospecting Session
out of state absentee ownersabsentee ownerscold callinglive prospectingreverse offer strategypocket buyer1 Deal A Week blueprint

Want more like this?

Join 1,500+ agents in the free 1 Deal A Week In Real Estate community.

Buying, selling or investing in Central PA? Visit Hampden Township Living, my local real estate site.
Let's chat with Josh →