Day four of our Tired Landlords series. Monday was why this audience. Tuesday was where to find them. Wednesday was exactly what to say. Today I put it together live in my market: build a pond, stock it, and start fishing.
Results vary, and nothing here is a guarantee. What I want you to see is the workflow. Call, voicemail, text, email, and when you need it, direct mail. Go deep on each card before you move on.
Build the pond before you fish
Before I dial anyone, I need a pond. I picked a small town in central Pennsylvania where I already have a reason to reach out: a relocating buyer who needs a home. That private client frame is my reason for the conversation.
I stacked filters to raise the odds. Tired landlord plus out of state absentee. In state absentee with an involuntary lien. A short list is fine. "How could you possibly do anything with five leads?" When you follow the whole process on each one, call, voicemail, text, email, maybe mail, you can turn a few of those into real opportunities.
The goal for a time block is simple. One hour, about eight to ten cards, and go deep. Most people who struggle with proactive prospecting never leave the shallow end.
Work one card all the way through
Once the deck is ready, I log into Lead Deck on my phone (it's a web app, not something you download from an app store), pick the audience and the sequence, and start tapping.
First card: tap to call. Voicemail. Leave the reverse offer voicemail. Then text: "Just left you a voicemail." Then email. If there are a few good emails, send them. Swap the first name when you're writing the spouse. Pattern recognition matters. A unique first.last@gmail plus a blue iMessage usually means you've got real contact info, so you may not need mail yet. Hit done for the week and clear the card.
When the numbers are dead, keep fishing
Next card had landlines that were disconnected. I hid each dead number so it doesn't waste time next pass. No working mobile, so I emailed the work and personal addresses that looked real, then tapped to enrich the card.
Enrichment runs more skip tracing so we get better data. Extra emails are free to send, so I send them. A mobile that comes back on the DNC isn't an automatic stop. Sometimes that number is publicly marketed, a Google Business Profile, a for rent listing. When it is, I treat it as fair game. When it isn't, I hide it and move to direct mail. Tap, add to the absentee owner mail list, and a letter goes out the next morning with the same "would you be open to an offer" message.
Stay curious when someone unexpected answers
One number rang a business. The person who picked up wasn't the owner. I stayed calm, said who I was trying to reach, and why: a private client interested in a property they own. Because I kept the conversation going, they offered to take my info and pass it along.
"When you just stay calm, relaxed, you ask good questions, and you're genuinely curious, good stuff can happen." Disarming tone beats slick and fast. Chat chimed in that dialing every number has often led to extended family who handed over the owner's contact. Same idea. Lean in. Don't marry yourself to one result on one call.
I still finished the card. Another mobile, another voicemail and text. A DNC mobile that wasn't publicly marketed got hidden. No email after enrich, so I added the card to mail before clearing it. I'm not done until I've exhausted the ways to get the message in front of the right person.
AI screening, funny voicemails and more lines in the water
Later cards brought the usual mix. An AI screener asked for name and purpose. I lean into that: who I am, who I'm trying to reach, and about which property. Then I leave the full reverse offer voicemail when it lets me.
One owner's outgoing voicemail was so funny I almost forgot to say I'd text from my personal cell. I still sent the text. If I'd already messaged months ago with no reply, I send again. Real person to real person. Blue bubble. Share your contact photo if your phone offers it. You're not hiding behind a burner dialer.
When two people own the property, leave voicemails and texts for both, and email both with the right first name. More lines in the water means they're more likely to talk to each other: did you get a message from that guy Josh?
A live reply, a remove me, and real estate go fish
Near the end of the hour I got a same day text reply. They weren't interested in an offer on that property. I thanked them and asked if they had any other properties they might consider an offer on. No isn't the end of the road.
Someone else said remove me. That doesn't bother me. I delete the card and move on. "All I'm doing is playing an infinite game of real estate go fish." Closure on the unfriendly ones lets me focus on people who are friendly, cooperative and open.
If an email delivers and they don't reply, the nudge comes later. Hitting reply with three question marks often doubles the response rate. Yes, no, good, bad. We're just trying to get an answer.
What's next in the series
That wraps week one on tired landlords and absentee owners. For the rest of the month we'll dig into the pieces: what to do when someone says yes, what to do when the first offer isn't a fit, and more live prospecting every Thursday.
If you want to work through this with other agents, join our free Skool community, 1 Deal A Week In Real Estate.
Key takeaways
- Build and stock a small pond first. Stack filters so you're reaching people who are more likely to transact.
- One hour, about eight to ten cards. Finish call, voicemail, text and email on each card before you move on.
- Dead numbers get hidden. Enrich when contact data is thin. Use direct mail when you're not sure the message will land.
- When someone unexpected answers, stay curious and disarming. Pass along your info when they offer.
- A no or a remove me is useful. Delete, clear the card, and keep playing real estate go fish.
- More lines in the water (phone, text, email, mail, both owners) means more bites later, not just during the live hour.
Chapters
- 00:00 Week one recap and today's plan
- 03:30 Free community resources
- 05:00 Why multiple ways to win with tired landlords
- 07:00 Choosing a pond with a private client reason
- 09:00 Stacking filters and stocking the deck
- 12:00 One hour, ten cards, go deep
- 14:30 Live prospecting: call, voicemail, text, email
- 19:30 Pattern recognition on contact data
- 21:00 Dead landlines, enrich and DNC checks
- 24:30 Direct mail when you need another line
- 25:30 Unexpected answer: stay curious
- 30:00 Finish the card anyway
- 36:00 Clearing the deck and picking another
- 38:00 AI call screening and reverse offer voicemail
- 44:00 Two owners, more lines in the water
- 49:00 Tweaking the text when voicemail fails
- 51:00 Live reply and go for the next no
- 52:30 Remove me is closure
- 53:30 What's next in the series
